Best Italian Pizza Restaurant in Rochester NY | Capones at Murphys Law | Pizza & Casual Dining

Order Now

Most-Loved Italian Classics

Discover the pizzas, sandwiches, and comfort food dishes our guests order again and again.

Order Now

Chicken Parmesan

pasta in red sauce with a breaded chicken cutlet, topped with melted mozzarella

Add Item

Broccoli Chicken Alfredo

Pasta with grilled chicken and broccoli in alfredo sauce

Add Item

Buffalo Chicken Calzone

Crispy chicken, blue cheese crumbles, and mozzarella

Add Item

Cheeseburger Plate

Two all beef patties on a bed of mac salad and home fries covered in meat sauce and drizzled in mustard

Add Item

Chicken Riggies

pasta in a spicy marinara with hot peppers and grilled chicken

Add Item

Order Your Favorites Online

Craving pizza, calzones, or Italian comfort food? Skip the wait and order online from Capone's at Murphy's Law. Enjoy quick pickup or convenient delivery throughout Rochester, including East Avenue, Downtown Rochester, Park Avenue, and surrounding neighborhoods. Fresh, delicious, and ready when you are.

Order Now

Proudly Serving the Heart of Rochester

Conveniently located on East Avenue, Capone's at Murphy's Law is surrounded by some of Rochester's most vibrant neighborhoods. Whether you're visiting Downtown Rochester, the Neighborhood of the Arts, or Park Avenue, we're the perfect stop for pizza, drinks, and Italian comfort food.

Visit Us

What Our Customers Are Saying

From first-time visitors to loyal regulars, hear what makes Capone's a local favorite.

Virginia

Food was delicious!!!!!!! Country sweet Chicken was very crispy, fries were seasoned. Everything was fresh, my daughter and I loved it so much. We will be returning!

American Patriot

Best dough around. The people that answer the phones are really respectful and well spoken. Went in before...Same deal. They know whats up. Keep up the good work. TY. Also the one star review R Smith...Ignore that. Anything can happen when ya order third party. I've eaten at all of the Capones. It's all consistent. ... This is a 10 star restaurant. Read More

David Vigliotti

I like it

Ebony Malone

Food is 10/10 definitely recommend and so fresh first time trying and I love it❤️

C M

Capone's at Murphy's Law Thank you so much! The owner was super chill and nice. Without us asking he immediately gave us this Really good chicken cutlet on the house 🙏🏽 so Grateful. 🫶🏾🫶🏾 I love me a good chicken cutlet 😁 OH and the woman taking the orders was so so friendly and welcoming. All around Great vibes 👌🏽👌🏽

James Simpson

The food was great and hit the spot. The staff were very friendly and fun. Would highly recommend!

Jarrid Rockwood

Ordered a medium sausage pizza thin crust and crispy with bbq wings. It came out perfect. Pizza had just the right amount of sauce and cheese with no flop! The wings were big and cooked perfect and the blue cheese was even better. Happy to have found my new favorite pizza place in Rochester !

Ross Morelli

Capone's at Murphys Law is Amazing! The food was delicious and the service was spot on!

Seth Warniaha

Delicious sub and pizza!

Claire Hardie

Excellent addition to East and Alex and it’s so nice to have someone great in the kitchen at Murphys again. I had the Big Dezie hot sub and it was fantastic, can’t wait to go back and try more!

Bri Rude

Amazing food with kind staff in kitchen and at bar! Will absolutely return

Eddy Brennessel

Great food, good price for portion sizes. Will return for more

Danielle Hall

The food was amazing! Large portions for sharing and still had leftovers! The pizza, spinach calzone, & chicken and vodka pasta dish were simply delicious. Will be back!